Loading EV catalog…

Tip: type Model Y vs Mach-E to compare any two EVs instantly Open full Compare Workbench →
Reliability & NHTSA Standing · 20 Qualifying EVs

Most Reliable Used EVs: Verified Best Years & Low-Risk Picks

Updated

Data-Backed Verdict

Top 3 data-backed picks: Rivian R1T, Subaru Solterra & Mercedes-Benz EQS Sedan & EQS SUV

Out of 82 active EV models on TrimIndex (NHTSA data through Nov 12, 2026), 20 qualify here. Leading the rankings are the Rivian R1T (270–420 mi, $57,300–$60,800), Subaru Solterra (222–288 mi, $20,200–$25,400) and Mercedes-Benz EQS Sedan & EQS SUV (277–390 mi, $33,000–$55,100). Select any 2–3 below to compare side by side.

Active-brand EVs with at least two judged model years, prioritizing TrimIndex verified Best Years first, then zero-avoid, zero-advisory-recall models ranked by composite score.

Data:NHTSA through

Full ranked table — tick any 2–3 EVs to compare side by side

Open unrestricted EV Compare Workbench →
20 of 20 shown
Compare#EV Model & TakeawayEPA Range / DCNHTSA StandingPort / SuperchargerUsed Price
1Rivian R1T (2022–2026)

Verified 2024 Best Year under age-matched NHTSA rules.

270–420 mi220 kW DCBest: 2024140 NHTSA cmplNACSYes, with its built-in NACS port$57,300–$60,800KBB · Nov 2026
2Subaru Solterra (2023–2026)

Verified 2024 Best Year under age-matched NHTSA rules.

222–288 mi100–150 kW DCBest: 202478 NHTSA cmplNACSYes, with its built-in NACS port$20,200–$25,400KBB · Nov 2026
3Mercedes-Benz EQS Sedan & EQS SUV (2022–2026)

Verified 2024 Best Year under age-matched NHTSA rules.

277–390 mi200 kW DCBest: 2024140 NHTSA cmplCCS1With an adapter, since February 2025$33,000–$55,100KBB · Nov 2026
4Ford F-150 Lightning (2022–2025)

Verified 2024 Best Year under age-matched NHTSA rules.

230–320 mi155 kW DCBest: 2024246 NHTSA cmplCCS1With an adapter$48,400–$60,300KBB · Nov 2026
5Ford Mustang Mach-E (2021–2026)

Verified 2024 Best Year under age-matched NHTSA rules (skip 2021).

211–320 mi150 kW DCBest: 2024 · Avoid: 2021689 NHTSA cmplCCS1With an adapter$22,800–$34,000KBB · Nov 2026
6Porsche Taycan (2020–2026)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2020–2026.

192–318 mi225–320 kW DCNo avoid year flagged280 NHTSA cmplCCS1With an adapter$44,700–$124,000KBB · Nov 2026
7Tesla Model 3 (2020–2026)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2020–2026.

Score: 59–78/100Compare Model 3 vs i4 →
220–363 mi100–250 kW DCNo avoid year flagged2,720 NHTSA cmplNACSYes, with its built-in NACS port$21,400–$42,700KBB · Nov 2026
8Tesla Model S (2020–2026)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2020–2026.

Score: 61–78/100Compare Model S vs Air →
287–410 mi200–250 kW DCNo avoid year flagged567 NHTSA cmplNACSYes, with its built-in NACS port$31,600–$86,000KBB · Nov 2026
9Hyundai Ioniq 6 (2023–2025)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2023–2025.

Score: 64–77/100Compare Ioniq 6 vs i4 →
240–361 mi235 kW DCNo avoid year flagged132 NHTSA cmplCCS1With an adapter, since Mar 25, 2025$21,400–$21,600KBB · Nov 2026
10Cadillac LYRIQ (2023–2026)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2023–2026.

285–326 mi190 kW DCNo avoid year flagged172 NHTSA cmplCCS1With an adapter$29,156–$44,772J.D. Power · Nov 2026
11Polestar 2 (2021–2025)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2021–2025.

Score: 61–76/100Compare 2 vs i4 →
233–320 mi150–205 kW DCNo avoid year flagged597 NHTSA cmplCCS1With an adapter$18,300–$30,200KBB · Nov 2026
12Audi Q4 e-tron (2022–2026)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2022–2026.

Score: 59–75/100Compare Q4 e-tron vs iX →
236–288 mi125–175 kW DCNo avoid year flagged76 NHTSA cmplCCS1No$22,700–$30,400KBB · Nov 2026
13Nissan ARIYA (2023–2026)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2023–2026.

205–304 mi130 kW DCNo avoid year flagged68 NHTSA cmplCCS1Status not on file$18,150–$29,400KBB · Nov 2026
14Rivian R1S (2022–2026)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2022–2026.

Score: 63–75/100Compare R1S vs EV9 →
270–410 mi220 kW DCNo avoid year flagged170 NHTSA cmplNACSYes, with its built-in NACS port$53,000–$59,500KBB · Nov 2026
15Tesla Model Y (2020–2026)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2020–2026.

244–357 mi170–250 kW DCNo avoid year flagged4,381 NHTSA cmplNACSYes, with its built-in NACS port$25,900–$39,300KBB · Nov 2026
16BMW i7 (2023–2026)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2023–2026.

285–321 mi195 kW DCNo avoid year flagged27 NHTSA cmplCCS1With an adapter$53,500–$73,000KBB · Nov 2026
17Genesis Electrified G80 (2023–2026)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2023–2026.

282–300 mi187 kW DCNo avoid year flaggedShared filingNACSYes, with its built-in NACS port$34,700–$35,100KBB · Nov 2026
18Kia Niro EV (2020–2026)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2020–2026.

239–253 mi85–100 kW DCNo avoid year flaggedShared filingCCS1With an adapter$14,300–$20,700KBB · Nov 2026
19Volvo XC40 Recharge (2021–2024)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2021–2024.

208–293 mi150 kW DCNo avoid year flagged101 NHTSA cmplCCS1With an adapter$21,700–$26,500KBB · Nov 2026
20Volvo C40 (2022–2024)

Zero flagged avoid years and 0 Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls across 2022–2024.

Score: 61–69/100Compare C40 vs Model Y →
226–297 mi150 kW DCNo avoid year flagged42 NHTSA cmplCCS1With an adapter$22,600–$25,500KBB · Nov 2026

Frequently asked questions

How does TrimIndex determine the most reliable used EVs?

TrimIndex compares each model’s judged model years over an identical age-matched NHTSA complaint window (files through Nov 12, 2026), checks against Cox Automotive calendar-year sales so popular cars aren’t penalized for fleet size, and checks for Park-Outside / Do-Not-Drive recalls and open defect investigations.

Which EV model years earn a verified TrimIndex Best Year badge?

Currently verified Best Years include 2024 Rivian R1T, 2024 Subaru Solterra, 2024 Mercedes-Benz EQS Sedan & EQS SUV, 2024 Ford F-150 Lightning, 2024 Ford Mustang Mach-E.

How does TrimIndex rank these used electric vehicles?

Every ranking pulls directly from TrimIndex’s verified database: EPA Fuel Economy Guide range and efficiency, NHTSA complaints and recalls through Nov 12, 2026, documented Tesla Supercharger access, and single-source KBB / J.D. Power used guides (with active US dealer asking ranges only where no guide exists yet). Bankrupt manufacturers without warranty support are excluded from Best lists (and flagged explicitly on the Used EVs to Avoid index).

Explore More Rankings