Loading EV catalog…

Tip: type Model Y vs Mach-E to compare any two EVs instantly Open full Compare Workbench →
Luxury & Performance Sedans · Head-to-Head

BMW i5 vs Tesla Model S

Updated

Swap either EV:vs

The Bottom Line

Tesla Model S leads by 100 miles at peak EPA range (410 vs 310 mi)

Neither the BMW i5 (2024–2026) nor the Tesla Model S (2020–2026) shows a single year-to-avoid spike per NHTSA records through Nov 12, 2026, putting EPA range and charging speed at the center of the choice. The Model S stands out for longer EPA range (up to 410 mi).

On EPA range, the Model S reaches 410 mi vs 310 mi for the i5; published used guides place the i5 at $41,400–$55,100 (KBB, Nov 2026) and the Model S at $31,600–$86,000 (KBB, Nov 2026).

Data:NHTSA through

BMW i5

2024–2026

Sedan · 8 canonical trims · AWD / RWD

BMW i5 (G60, 2024-)
No standout bad year on file

EPA Range

253–310 mi

Latest Port

CCS1

KBB Used

$41,400–$55,100

Tesla Model S

2020–2026

Sedan · 16 canonical trims · AWD

Tesla Model S (2021 refresh)
No standout bad year on file

EPA Range

287–410 mi

Latest Port

NACS

KBB Used

$31,600–$86,000

Pick the BMW i5 if…

  • Lower original sticker price — i5 trims started at $66,800 original MSRP vs $76,190 on the Model S.

Pick the Tesla Model S if…

  • Maximum EPA range matters most — the Model S reaches 410 mi vs 310 mi on the i5.
  • Lower energy use per mile — best Model S trims rate 27.1 kWh/100 mi vs 30.6 kWh/100 mi on the i5.
  • Built-in Tesla Supercharger access without an adapter — Model S ships with native NACS, whereas i5 uses CCS1 (Combined Charging System).
  • Lower used-market entry price — KBB starts at $31,600 for the Model S vs $41,400 for the i5 (KBB).
01 · Year-Matched Diff

Compare matching model years side by side

2024 BMW i5 vs 2024 Tesla Model S

Pick a shared model year to compare matching EPA range, NHTSA filings, charging port and published pricing.

2024 Model Year · 2 trims

2024 BMW i5

Judged
EPA Range
256–295 mi

Efficiency: 32.2–37.0 kWh/100 mi · Up to 205 kW DC

NHTSA complaints
21
NHTSA recalls
10
Open investigations
0
Fast-charge port
CCS1 (Combined Charging System)
Supercharger access
With an adapter
NHTSA crash rating
Not rated
PricingKBB · Nov 2026
$41,400–$55,100
Top owner complaint theme
Brake recall repair delayed for parts — 6 of 21 complaints (29%)

2024 Model Year · 2 trims

2024 Tesla Model S

Judged
EPA Range
+107 mi max359–402 mi

Efficiency: 27.7–31.5 kWh/100 mi · Up to 250 kW DC

NHTSA complaints
38
NHTSA recalls
6
Open investigations
4
Fast-charge port
NACS (SAE J3400)
Supercharger access
Yes, with its built-in NACS port
NHTSA crash rating
Not rated
PricingKBB · Nov 2026
$69,000–$86,000
Top owner complaint theme
Lane departure alarms jerk steering — 17 of 38 complaints (45%)
02 · Reliability & Safety Record

Years to avoid, recalls & recurring problems

Aligned year by year from NHTSA complaint, recall and defect-investigation files through Nov 12, 2026 (investigations through Nov 13, 2026). Complaint counts are raw totals on file, never fleet-normalized failure rates.

Year BMW i5 Tesla Model S
Yr Standing / Port NHTSA Record Range & Price Standing / Port NHTSA Record Range & Price
2026 Too new CCS1 2 cmpl 2 rec 277–310 mi $54,667–$83,945 (Asking · Nov 2026) Too new NACS 8 cmpl 0 rec · 1 open 368–410 mi Sold new
2025 Too new CCS1 8 cmpl 5 rec 253–295 mi $43,374–$69,942 (Asking · Nov 2026) Too new NACS 6 cmpl 2 rec · 3 open 348–410 mi $74,999–$119,800 (Asking · Nov 2026)
2024 Judged CCS1 21 cmpl 10 rec 256–295 mi $41,400–$55,100 (KBB) Judged NACS 38 cmpl 6 rec · 4 open 359–402 mi $69,000–$86,000 (KBB)
2023 Not sold in 2023 Judged NACS 115 cmpl 13 rec · 4 open 405 mi $53,000 (KBB)
2022 Not sold in 2022 Judged NACS 141 cmpl 20 rec · 4 open 396–405 mi $44,500–$54,300 (KBB)
2021 Not sold in 2021 Judged NACS 179 cmpl 24 rec · 4 open 348–405 mi $38,900–$51,600 (KBB)
2020 Not sold in 2020 Judged NACS 80 cmpl 11 rec · 4 open 287–402 mi $26,833–$34,575 (J.D. Power)

Click any year row to open that model year’s trim comparison, full recall campaign list and complaint themes. Years sold fewer than 30 months are marked Too new.

Rows marked Asking show aggregated active US used dealer listings where no KBB or J.D. Power guide price is on file yet (asking prices, not final sale prices; excluded from Value-to-Score).

Most repeated owner complaint patterns (NHTSA)

No multi-year recurring complaint theme is grouped for the BMW i5 yet.

Tesla Model S

Full list →

driver-assist and self-driving features

47 complaints across 5 model years (2021: 11 of 179 (6%); 2022: 4 of 141 (3%); 2023: 6 of 115 (5%); 2024: 21 of 38 (55%); 2026: 5 of 8 (63%)).

“The vehicle also jerked the steering wheel towards the wall. I have all lane departure warnings, and assistance settings turned off.”

sudden braking with nothing ahead

94 complaints across 4 model years (2020: 22 of 80 (28%); 2021: 34 of 179 (19%); 2022: 30 of 141 (21%); 2023: 8 of 115 (7%)).

“When using adaptive cruise control vehicle randomly applies brakes while driving at highway speeds, for no reason.”

tires, wheels and alignment

44 complaints across 4 model years (2020: 3 of 80 (4%); 2021: 17 of 179 (9%); 2022: 18 of 141 (13%); 2023: 6 of 115 (5%)).

“Rear tires have alarming wear on the inside, where the inside sidewall meets the tread.”

03 · Battery & Fast Charging

Pack hardware, measured SoH & Tesla Supercharger access

Battery capacity readings come strictly from verified individual owner or per-car reports on file — never modeled projections. Charging port and Supercharger access come from automaker and Tesla documents.

BMW i5 Battery

NMC
Usable pack capacity
79.0 kWh
Thermal management
refrigerant
Battery warranty
8 years or 100,000 miles

Measured Battery-Health Readings on File

No verified individual owner battery-health readings are on file for this pack yet.

Tesla Model S Battery

NCA
Usable pack capacity
Not on file
Thermal management
liquid active
Battery warranty
8 years or 150,000 miles

Measured Battery-Health Readings on File

4 verified individual-car readings spanning 85%–97% capacity (11,186–137,944 mi).

Fast-charging ports & Tesla Supercharger access by model year

Several EVs transitioned from CCS1 to built-in NACS between 2024 and 2026. Check the exact model year before assuming adapter needs.

BMW i5

Up to 205 kW DC
Model years 2024–2026 CCS1 (Combined Charging System)

Tesla Superchargers: With an adapter

Adapter note: From a maker-approved supplier, price not stated

Source: BMW of North America (undated page, archived copy captured Oct 30, 2026); BMW of North America (published Oct 17, 2023; archived copy captured Oct 14, 2024)

Tesla Model S

Up to 250 kW DC
Model years 2020–2026 NACS (SAE J3400)

Tesla Superchargers: Yes, with its built-in NACS port

Source: Tesla, Inc. (published Nov 11, 2022; archived copy captured Apr 6, 2025); Tesla, Inc. (undated page, archived copy captured Apr 1, 2025)

04 · Used Pricing & Value

Published market guides & original MSRP

Every published used-market figure stays attributed to a single source (Kelley Blue Book or J.D. Power) with its collection window — never blended across sources.

BMW i5

2024–2026

KBB Used Range · Nov 2026

$41,400–$55,100

Covers model year 2024 · trim-level guide pricing

Original MSRP Span

$66,800–$84,100

Value-to-Score Ratio

5–6/10

Tesla Model S

2020–2026

KBB Used Range · Nov 2026

$31,600–$86,000

Covers model years 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 · trim-level guide pricing

J.D. Power Used Range · Nov 2026

$26,833–$34,575

Covers model year 2020 · model-year guide pricing

Original MSRP Span

$76,190–$137,190

Value-to-Score Ratio

1–9/10

Georgia Tax-Assessed Value (Separate State Tax Schedule)

Georgia Department of Revenue Assessment Manual (2026 edition)

These figures come from the Georgia Department of Revenue Motor Vehicle Assessment Manual for Title Ad Valorem Tax (TAVT) under O.C.G.A. § 48-5C-1(a)(1). They are state tax-assessment values, not market prices, guide estimates or dealer offers, and are never blended into Value-to-Score calculations.

BMW i5

  • 2026 model year $52,800–$56,825
  • 2025 model year $47,100–$62,175
  • 2024 model year $40,925–$55,425

Tesla Model S

  • 2025 model year $56,700–$68,825
  • 2024 model year $48,400–$61,150
  • 2023 model year $40,600–$52,025
  • 2022 model year $33,350–$45,325
  • 2021 model year $29,650–$29,950
  • 2020 model year $21,625–$25,225

The federal §25E used-EV tax credit expired in September 2025. State and utility incentives vary by residency, income and price caps — check each trim page’s State Incentive Finder for current state rules.

05 · Specifications & Crash Ratings

Specs & NHTSA 5-Star safety compared

Specification BMW i5 Tesla Model S
EPA range (all trims) EPA Fuel Economy Guide 253–310 mi 287–410 mi
Energy consumption (lower is better) EPA Fuel Economy Guide 30.6–37.5 kWh/100 mi 27.1–33.4 kWh/100 mi
Combined MPGe EPA Fuel Economy Guide 90–110 MPGe 101–124 MPGe
Usable battery capacity 79.0 kWh Not on file
Peak DC fast charging 205 kW 200–250 kW
Rated horsepower Manufacturer rated output 335–593 hp 670 hp
Drivetrains offered AWD, RWD AWD
Seating capacity 5 seats Not on file
Body style Sedan Sedan
Owner Forum Posts

What owners write about on EV forums & Reddit

Filtered to posts written by owners of each model year under TrimIndex’s owner-relevance rule. Topic counts reflect what owners discuss most often.

BMW i5

3 owner posts on file

“Lease Transfer - 2024 BMW i5 M60 in FL - $1,193 - <19 months Figured I would post here before putting on swapalease but no longer need two cars and looking to swap my 2024 BMW i5 M60 that is in perfect condition, never smoked in, carefully…”

“I'm encouraged by the mi/kWh that drivers are getting, but alas I'm avg 3.3 mi/kWh in my i5 M Sport on 21 in tires. That's up slightly from the 3.2 I got in July, according to the myBMW app Sounds about right. I opted for the 20” for a…”

Tesla Model S

42 owner posts on file
Overall satisfaction: 12 Software and tech: 12 Build quality: 10 Range: 6

“I own a 2020 Model S extended range and have continued issues with my side mirrors not auto-folding (based on location) as they should because that setting is set. What happens is that sometimes (~20%) the mirrors will randomly auto-fold…”

“Sitting at the supercharger for 20-30 minutes isn't the worst thing in the world, playing games, playing on phone, etc., but it's still not as good as sitting at home on the couch or recliner while your car charges nicely overnight back up…”

06 · Before You Sign

Pre-purchase inspection checklist for this pair

Pair-specific checks built from active recall advisories, open NHTSA investigations, top complaint patterns and charging hardware.

1
Inspect Model S

Review open NHTSA investigation EA26002 (2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026)

NHTSA has an open defect investigation on Model S (EA26002). Check service records for related repairs or pending software updates.

2
Inspect Model S

Test and inspect for driver-assist and self-driving features (47 complaints across 5 years)

This is the most recurring complaint pattern across Tesla Model S model years on file (2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2026). Ask for full service history before purchase.

BMW i5 vs Tesla Model S frequently asked questions

What model years should you avoid on the BMW i5 vs Tesla Model S?

For the BMW i5 (2024–2026), no single model year is flagged to avoid (31 NHTSA complaints on file). For the Tesla Model S (2020–2026), no single model year is flagged to avoid (567 NHTSA complaints on file). Every comparison uses age-matched NHTSA filings (NHTSA data through Nov 12, 2026).

Which has better range and faster charging: BMW i5 or Tesla Model S?

Across active trims on file from the EPA Fuel Economy Guide, the BMW i5 spans 253–310 mi and the Tesla Model S spans 287–410 mi. Efficiency: i5 rates 31–38 kWh/100 mi; Model S rates 27–33 kWh/100 mi. Fast charging on file: i5 peaks at 205 kW DC; Model S peaks at 250 kW DC.

Can the BMW i5 and Tesla Model S use Tesla Superchargers?

BMW i5 (CCS1 (Combined Charging System)): with an adapter. Tesla Model S (NACS (SAE J3400)): yes, with its built-in nacs port. Status reflects automaker and Tesla documentation on file at TrimIndex.

Which costs less used: the BMW i5 or the Tesla Model S?

Published KBB used-market figures (Nov 2026) place BMW i5 trims at $41,400–$55,100. Published KBB used-market figures (Nov 2026) place Tesla Model S trims at $31,600–$86,000. Each range reflects a single pricing source rather than blended estimates; inspect individual model-year and trim pages for trim-specific pricing.

What are the most common problems reported on the BMW i5 vs Tesla Model S?

The BMW i5 has no multi-year recurring complaint theme on file yet. On the Tesla Model S, the largest multi-year complaint pattern is driver-assist and self-driving features (47 complaints across 5 model years). These reflect shares of NHTSA owner complaints on file, not fleet-wide failure rates.

How do the BMW i5 and Tesla Model S batteries and warranties compare?

BMW i5: NMC cells, 79.0 kWh usable, 8 years or 100,000 miles battery warranty. Tesla Model S: NCA cells, 8 years or 150,000 miles battery warranty, 4 verified owner capacity readings (85%–97%). Capacity readings reflect individual verified owner reports on file rather than modeled estimates.

What this comparison is built on

NHTSA Filings

Through Nov 12, 2026

EPA & NCAP

24 canonical trims

Owner Forum Posts

45 verified owner posts

Related EV comparisons

Browse all 300 comparisons →

Photo credits